Available

16640 Marshfield Ave

Markham, IL 60428

3 bed1 bath1,000 sqft6,600 sqft lot
$1,700/moVerified rent, not a projection. The prior tenant paid $1,700 a month. This is a rent roll number off an occupied unit, not a market guess. The tenant moved out September 1, 2026 and the house is delivered vacant.

Investment Calculator

Line itemAmount
Purchase price$142,000
Buy-side closing2% of purchase$2,840
Rehab to rent-readyCosmetic turn — see the repair list below$10,000
All-in basis$154,840
Verified rentWhat the last tenant actually paid, not a market estimate$1,700/mo
Operating expenses50% rule — taxes, insurance, vacancy, maintenance, management(850)
Monthly NOI$10,200/yr · 6.6% cap rate on all-in · 7.6 GRM$850/mo

NOI is before debt service. Financed, subtract the mortgage payment to get cash flow. The 50% expense rule is a screening assumption, not an operating budget — a buyer should underwrite actual taxes, insurance and management for this specific property.

Rent and tenancy

Last collected rent$1,700/mo
Gross annual rent$20,400
OccupancyDelivered vacant
Tenant moved outSep 1, 2026

The house rented at this number in its current condition, so the rent side of the underwriting is history rather than a forecast. It comes to you empty, which means a buyer can turn it, re-list it and set the new rent themselves instead of inheriting a lease and a tenant they did not screen.

Why this market

Four closed sales inside a few blocks bracket this house between $215,000 and $245,000, and every one of them settled — there is not an asking price in the set. 16607 Winchester is the tightest read: three bedrooms, two baths and the same thousand square feet, closed at $226,000 this year. On this block, 16544 Marshfield sits on the same 6,600 square foot lot with the same detached two-car garage, and came back finished at $245,000 eight months after trading distressed at $115,000. 16341 Justine closed at $239,000 off a 2025 remodel, and 281 E 163rd in Harvey settled at $215,000 in June with five bedrooms and more square footage than this house — the floor of the range rather than the ceiling. A $230,000 resale sits in the middle of that band, not at the top of it. The rent side needs no forecast at all — the house collected $1,700 a month in the condition you are seeing it in.

Comparable sales

Anchor compClosed sale16607 Winchester Ave, Markham3 bd / 2 ba · ~1,000 sqft · built 1959 · a few blocks westThree bedrooms, two baths and the same thousand square feet as this house, closed this year. It is the only comp in the set that has actually settled at this level, and it is what the $230,000 resale is built on.$226,000Sold 2026Zillow
Closed sale16544 Marshfield Ave, Markham4 bd / 1.5 ba · 1,040 sqft · built 1965 · 6,599 sqft lot · same blockSame block, forty square feet larger, on the same 6,600 square foot lot with the same detached two-car garage. It traded distressed at $115,000 in October 2025 and came back finished at $245,000 eight months later. The round trip is what tells you the finish is worth on this street.$245,000Sold 06/2026Zillow
Closed sale16341 Justine St, Markham3 bd / 2 ba · built 1963 · rehabbed 2025A finished Markham three-bedroom that settled at $239,000 off a 2025 remodel. Same bed count as this house, and it closed nine thousand above the resale number this deal is written to.$239,000Sold 09/2025Zillow
Closed sale281 E 163rd St, Harvey5 bd / 2 ba · 1,158 sqft · built 1973Closed at $215,000 in Harvey this June. It is the floor of the set — five bedrooms and more square footage than this house, in a weaker submarket — which is what makes it the useful downside check.$215,000Sold 06/2026Zillow

Repairs

Estimated finish budget: $10,000 depending on contractor.

  • Interior paint throughout — scuffs and patch marks left by the tenant ($2,500–3,500)
  • One damaged interior door — hole punched through the panel ($150)
  • Nail-hole patches and touch-ups
  • Landscaping — front yard is badly overgrown ($400)
  • Deep clean and make-ready for lease